The Pretty Cakery

The Pretty Cakery Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from The Pretty Cakery, Coffee shop, 112 S. Main Street, Nappanee, IN.
(76)

Operating as usual

Happy Saturday! 🤩 Stop by and allow us to warm your heart and hands. We love to serve and take care of our amazing custo...
02/06/2021

Happy Saturday! 🤩
Stop by and allow us to warm your heart and hands. We love to serve and take care of our amazing customers 💗

Nothing says "I love you" like these adorable personal heart shaped cheesecakes!! Available in vanilla raspberry swirl o...
02/05/2021

Nothing says "I love you" like these adorable personal heart shaped cheesecakes!! Available in vanilla raspberry swirl or chocolate raspberry swirl for $3.75 ea. Or get two for you and your sweetheart for $7. ❤️❤️❤️

This cake will have you going bananas! Available by the slice, our banana cream cake is baked with fresh bananas, filled...
02/05/2021

This cake will have you going bananas! Available by the slice, our banana cream cake is baked with fresh bananas, filled with delicious cream cheese filling, and iced with our amazing vanilla buttercream!

NEW to our showcase a peanut butter chocolate eclair!! Our house made light choux pastry filled with peanut butter pastr...
02/04/2021

NEW to our showcase a peanut butter chocolate eclair!! Our house made light choux pastry filled with peanut butter pastry cream, dipped in a silky chocolate ganache! And to top it all off, chopped Reese's! 😍🤩

Our turtle cheesecake will be available in our showcase today! Delicious house made vanilla cheesecake, beautifully topp...
02/04/2021

Our turtle cheesecake will be available in our showcase today! Delicious house made vanilla cheesecake, beautifully topped with drizzles of chocolate, caramel & chopped pecans!!

Our fun and delicious CHERRY MILKSHAKE CUPCAKES are back 😍 these cupcakes will available until February 13th. Don’t miss...
02/03/2021

Our fun and delicious CHERRY MILKSHAKE CUPCAKES are back 😍 these cupcakes will available until February 13th.

Don’t miss out on having the best time ever with your eyes, tastebuds, and heart ❤️ these cupcakes are the best!

These FUN and FESTIVE cookies are available starting today! We will have them available until February 13th. ❤️❤️Our del...
02/02/2021

These FUN and FESTIVE cookies are available starting today! We will have them available until February 13th. ❤️❤️

Our delicious chocolate chip cookies filled with our amazing creamy vanilla buttercream, rolled in love sprinkles, topped with some glitter. ❤️🤩

They make perfect and fun gifts and treats, for yourself or someone special in your life 💗 stop by and pick some up today or order some for Valentine’s Day 🥰

They are $3.50 each. 1 cookie in a bag.

Sunshine and our Ultimate Caramel Latte. Beautiful beginning to a beautiful day! 🤩Doing something to help you feel happy...
02/02/2021

Sunshine and our Ultimate Caramel Latte. Beautiful beginning to a beautiful day! 🤩Doing something to help you feel happy in the morning is important and will help you have a wonderful day!

What are some things you like to do to make yourself smile? Some things I like to do....

Enjoy a caffeinated beverage. ☕️
Spend time with my baby girl; her sweet smiling face always makes me happy 😊
Spend time in gratitude; it always makes my heart happy. ❤️

Celebrating life with beautiful delicious food is the best! #cakesbyjodi #celebratelife #beautifulfood
01/30/2021

Celebrating life with beautiful delicious food is the best! #cakesbyjodi #celebratelife #beautifulfood

It’s a great day to enjoy a nice hot caffeinated beverage at The Pretty Cakery. Take some time for yourself, think about...
01/30/2021

It’s a great day to enjoy a nice hot caffeinated beverage at The Pretty Cakery. Take some time for yourself, think about the week you had, and celebrate all the big and small things you have to be grateful for 💞

💞Latte Love is in the air 💞 Stop by and try a drink from our Valentine’s Drink menu 😍 treat yourself and maybe buy one f...
01/29/2021

💞Latte Love is in the air 💞
Stop by and try a drink from our Valentine’s Drink menu 😍 treat yourself and maybe buy one for a friend also.

Happy Thursday! We have our AMAZING Carrot Cake available in the showcase! Carrots=vegetables, our carrot cake= good for...
01/28/2021

Happy Thursday! We have our AMAZING Carrot Cake available in the showcase! Carrots=vegetables, our carrot cake= good for you and your taste buds 😉 stop by this week and grab a slice.... or five. you do you!

This delicious beauty is back! the cinnamon roll cheesecake will be available by the slice in our showcase starting toda...
01/27/2021

This delicious beauty is back! the cinnamon roll cheesecake will be available by the slice in our showcase starting today; only while supply lasts. RUN don't walk, we always sell out quick! .... but be careful it's icy out! 😉

Another awesome cake from the Cakes by Jodi menu. Where are the chocolate lovers? This one is for you 🤗 This is our Trip...
01/27/2021

Another awesome cake from the Cakes by Jodi menu. Where are the chocolate lovers? This one is for you 🤗
This is our Triple Chocolate Cake! Chocolate cake filled with layers of our decadent chocolate ganache, iced with our all-butter chocolate buttercream, and topped with a silky chocolate ganache🍫

A Wonder Woman Unicorn cake. All the magic and power in one cake!!  🎂
01/26/2021

A Wonder Woman Unicorn cake. All the magic and power in one cake!! 🎂

Food is a beautiful and a sensual experience gift. Nothing engages all of our senses like eating delicious food. We are ...
01/26/2021

Food is a beautiful and a sensual experience gift. Nothing engages all of our senses like eating delicious food. We are doing our beautiful and fun Valentine boxes again. Treat yourself, the one you love, or someone special in your life that deserves to know you care about them. 💗
Pictured is our Deluxe Box.
We will also have our sandwich cookies packaged and available for order for $3.50 each.
Don’t wait until last minute. Our schedule is already filling up with sweet Valentine orders 😊

So excited about 2021 wedding season! How beautiful is this cake I created for a photo shoot!
01/26/2021

So excited about 2021 wedding season! How beautiful is this cake I created for a photo shoot!

Happy Monday! We hope your week is starting off “sweet!” 🤍 This stunning cake and macaron combination was made by The Pretty Cakery!



Photography: Forever Images by Melissa Ann, LLC
Florals: Snapdragon-Designs
Design/Rentals: AAYS Event Rentals
#theweddingmag #wedding #weddingplanning #weddinginspiration #weddingcake #cakedesign #cakeinspiration #frenchcountrywedding #frenchcountry #frenchcountrycake #macaronsofinstagram #weddingmacarons #indianawedding #michianawedding #michianabride

Happy Sunny Saturday! 😊Notice: We will be closing at 1 o’clock today. Wishing you an awesome weekend my friend! Don’t mi...
01/23/2021

Happy Sunny Saturday! 😊
Notice: We will be closing at 1 o’clock today. Wishing you an awesome weekend my friend! Don’t miss out on stopping by to pick up some treats for your weekend!

A perfect cake for a little boy that loves big boy toys! 😄
01/23/2021

A perfect cake for a little boy that loves big boy toys! 😄

What's not to LOVE about our simply sweet caramel macchiato! Beautifully drizzled with delicious caramel. To be enjoyed ...
01/22/2021

What's not to LOVE about our simply sweet caramel macchiato! Beautifully drizzled with delicious caramel. To be enjoyed hot or iced! 💕

The ultimate Caramel Latte in the ultimate sunshine! ☀️☀️
01/21/2021

The ultimate Caramel Latte in the ultimate sunshine! ☀️☀️

It is a double shot espresso only... kind of day ☕️ Let’s go make it an awesome day! 🤩
01/21/2021

It is a double shot espresso only... kind of day ☕️ Let’s go make it an awesome day! 🤩

Another delicious cake ordered from the Cakes by Jodi menu. This beauty is the Mocha Caramel Cake. Rich chocolate cake f...
01/20/2021

Another delicious cake ordered from the Cakes by Jodi menu. This beauty is the Mocha Caramel Cake. Rich chocolate cake filled with layers of caramel espresso filling, iced with espresso buttercream and with a caramel drizzle 😍

From the NEW Cakes by Jodi menu!! We have Birthday Cake Cheesecake and Jodi’s “favorite cake” Raspberry Cream Cake. Avai...
01/20/2021

From the NEW Cakes by Jodi menu!! We have Birthday Cake Cheesecake and Jodi’s “favorite cake” Raspberry Cream Cake. Available by the slice in the showcase! 😍

A fun beginning to our day 🤩🥳 Celebrating life with you!
01/20/2021

A fun beginning to our day 🤩🥳 Celebrating life with you!

Come in for this fan favorite; our Sticky Bun Latte!! A perfect blend of caramel, cinnamon and hazelnut; we even brew th...
01/20/2021

Come in for this fan favorite; our Sticky Bun Latte!! A perfect blend of caramel, cinnamon and hazelnut; we even brew the espresso with cinnamon to boost the flavor! Topped with our delicious house made whipped topping!!! You won't be able to resist this one! 🤤🥰

‼️NEW TO THE SHOWCASE‼️ White Chip Lemon Streusel Bars! Baked with fresh squeezed lemon juice and zest. Topped with butt...
01/19/2021

‼️NEW TO THE SHOWCASE‼️
White Chip Lemon Streusel Bars! Baked with fresh squeezed lemon juice and zest. Topped with buttery streusel crumble, white chocolate chips, and a white chocolate drizzle. This decadent bar will have you feeling happy, happy, happy 😃
Stop by and celebrate yourself today.! You are special, one of a kind, and deserve to be celebrated for being who you are.

Happy Tuesday 💗 Calling the chocolate lovers! Our iced Café Mocha paired with our Fudge Sundae Cupcake is the best kind ...
01/19/2021

Happy Tuesday 💗 Calling the chocolate lovers! Our iced Café Mocha paired with our Fudge Sundae Cupcake is the best kind of double fisting!! 😉🍫

How fun are these Birthday Cake Cheesecakes!! If you haven’t already, you should check out our new Cakes by Jodi menu! O...
01/16/2021

How fun are these Birthday Cake Cheesecakes!! If you haven’t already, you should check out our new Cakes by Jodi menu! Our delicious Birthday Cake Cheesecake is on that menu 😋

To kickstart your morning and to add a little pep in your step, we propose our Dirty Vanilla Chai Latte! Chai Tea with a...
01/16/2021

To kickstart your morning and to add a little pep in your step, we propose our Dirty Vanilla Chai Latte! Chai Tea with a shot of espresso... the PERFECT amount of caffeine to get you going! deliciously paired with our lovely raspberry white chocolate scone, ideal for on the go!

Our Lemon Honey Lavender Cake. One of the many delicious cakes from our new Cakes By Jodi menu! 🤩Delicious Lemon cake ma...
01/15/2021

Our Lemon Honey Lavender Cake. One of the many delicious cakes from our new Cakes By Jodi menu! 🤩
Delicious Lemon cake made with fresh squeezed lemon juice and zest, filled with layers of honey lavender filling, iced with lavender buttercream, topped with honey and edible lavender flowers.

Such a privilege and honor being a part of this 💗
01/15/2021
TheWeddingMag - Michiana 20/21

Such a privilege and honor being a part of this 💗

Michiana's number one wedding resource. Plan, connect and be inspired by your wedding professionals in Northern Indiana and Southwest Michigan.

Creamy decadent Cookies and Cream Cheesecake available by the slice in our showcase 🤩
01/15/2021

Creamy decadent Cookies and Cream Cheesecake available by the slice in our showcase 🤩

Who wants to try this with me 😂
01/15/2021

Who wants to try this with me 😂

Had so much fun with this cake! Edible art and helping people celebrate life! It’s the best 🤩 #firetruckcake #edibleart ...
01/14/2021

Had so much fun with this cake! Edible art and helping people celebrate life! It’s the best 🤩 #firetruckcake #edibleart #celebratelife #cakesbyjodi

Address

112 S. Main Street
Nappanee, IN
46550

Opening Hours

Tuesday 09:00 - 17:00
Wednesday 09:00 - 17:00
Thursday 09:00 - 17:00
Friday 09:00 - 17:00
Saturday 09:00 - 15:00

Telephone

(574) 221-2207

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Pretty Cakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Videos

Category

Nearby restaurants


Other Coffee Shops in Nappanee

Show All

Comments

Hello The Pretty Cakery, Your cake seems to be featured on page [11] here http://bit.ly/2Yfg1GX. How you take part on this?
The Pretty Cakery is hands down the best cake around! In the last 4 months we’ve gotten 3 cakes from her! Strawberry chip for my 29th birthday, volleyball cupcakes for our youngests volleyball tournament, and a Devils Food/Cherry Chip for my husbands 40th. They have all be so delicious and decorated SO CUTE!
Thanks so much everyone just loved it
The cake was fabulous and all gone! Wish I'd gotten a better picture.
Thank you, Kim, for your kind words and stopping to pray. You are a blessing!
Thank you so much for doing our cake and cupcakes for our wedding. They were delicious and everyone loved them!
Your cupcakes were fantastic and a big hit at today’s bridal shower!
VERY VERY VERY happy with how our cakes turned out!!! You do such an amazing job and I will definitely be returning!!!
Loved my pink box of treasures today! :) The macarons and ham and cheese crostata are always favorites. However a new favorite has emerged... the lime blackberry cheesecake! Wow, love that lime flavor, especially topped with that divine blackberry sauce! I think I will order a whole cheesecake for my next carry-in... and then cancel the gathering so I can eat the whole thing by myself! :D Haha!
Thank you for creating the beautiful cake to celebrate our beautiful Cassidy!
Delicious! If anyone hasn’t tried these buttermilk frosted cookies then they are missing out! Not pictured is a chocolate eclair and a brownie that had already been enjoyed. So glad to have the Pretty Cakery in Nappanee!
Thank you, Jodi for another beautiful and delicious cake! It was a big hit at my nephews 1st birthday party! 💙