Classy Girl Rebaked

Classy Girl Rebaked We appreciate your patience, the new Classy Girl Rebaked is in the works! See you soon! xoxo
(477)

We are not yet accepting orders, but feel free to reach out to us on our socials or email for future order info. **Carryout Menu of daily flavors changes monthly, see pinned menu for today’s flavors. Call ahead or simply stop in to purchase from daily menu! :) **

Custom cake & cupcake orders can be placed with 3-5 days notice! Here are 3 ways you can pre-order:
(phone) 414/270-1877
(email) [email protected]
(online) ClassyGirlCupcakes.com

Thank you for all of your support!

Still prepping for that summer bod? Good luck... things are happening! Stay tuned Milwaukee! 😝🧁🍪😋
03/29/2026

Still prepping for that summer bod? Good luck... things are happening! Stay tuned Milwaukee! 😝🧁🍪😋

🧁👚Last minute merch sale!☕️🤓 We found some fun t-shirts, greeting cards, tattoos, and more, and would love to pass on th...
12/31/2025

🧁👚Last minute merch sale!☕️🤓
We found some fun t-shirts, greeting cards, tattoos, and more, and would love to pass on the nostalgia to you before they’re gone forever🥲 Scroll through, photos are in order of items listed, quantities available in parentheses. Comment below if you’d like to purchase something, and we’ll go in order til they’re gone. DM to arrange pickup, shipping of most items available for a fee. Payment by Venmo or credit card (through Square invoice how we used to invoice for bakery orders). Happy New Year, and cheers to 15 years!🥂

👚Cupcakes Make Everything Better: $10
*Canvas brand berry short sleeve t-shirt with white graphic, unisex sizing
*Small (3)
*Medium (13)
*Large (8)
*XL SOLD OUT
*2XL SOLD OUT

👚Heart for Baking: $10
*Canvas brand grey short sleeve t-shirt with pink graphic, unisex sizing
*XS (6)
*Small (5)
*Medium (6)
*Large (6)

👚Milwaukee spelled out in baking implements: $10
*Canvas brand black short sleeve t-shirt with white graphic, unisex sizing
*XS (3)

👚Wisconsin Outline: $10
*Canvas brand heather red short sleeve t-shirt with white graphic, unisex sizing
*XS (3)

👚Life Is How You Bake It: SOLD OUT
*Next Level brand white short sleeve t-shirt with multicolor graphic, child sizing
*XS child size 4-5 (0)

☕️Set of 4 ceramic logo mugs: SOLD OUT
*10oz, 2 were used as pen holders, we washed them but you can probably do a better job:), no chips, one set available, prefer not to ship these

📔Pack of 10 assorted greeting cards with envelopes: $10
*May include Milwaukee spelled out in baking implements, heart graphic, and Cupcake Crew characters (no requests, you get what you get:), 6 available packs of 10

💘Cupcake Crew temporary tattoos: $10
*Several hundred, one lot available

☕️12 sleeves of 50 (600 total) white paper disposable hot drink cups, 16oz, no lids: $20 for all (not shippable)

Today is the last day for Classy Girl Cupcakes!We’d love for you to stop in and say goodbye and of course get some sweet...
12/23/2025

Today is the last day for Classy Girl Cupcakes!We’d love for you to stop in and say goodbye and of course get some sweet treats!

Stay tuned for more info on what’s next from the Classy Girls… ❤️💚

❄️❄️❄️For the safety of our employees and our customers, we will be closing at 1:00pm tomorrow, 11/29.❄️❄️❄️
11/29/2025

❄️❄️❄️For the safety of our employees and our customers, we will be closing at 1:00pm tomorrow, 11/29.❄️❄️❄️

Today was our 15th birthday, and it will be our last. Classy Girl Cupcakes will be open until Tuesday, December 23, 2025...
11/24/2025

Today was our 15th birthday, and it will be our last. Classy Girl Cupcakes will be open until Tuesday, December 23, 2025, then we will close permanently. I know we will leave a cupcake shaped hole in the heart of this community, as nobody does what we do, the way we do it. It has been the honor of my life to be invited into your lives to share so many special moments❤️

Doing what we do is expensive. Every time I raise prices due to skyrocketing costs, I hope the business we lose reduces how hard my employees have to work, but it never quite happens. We are so busy, too busy at times, but still we can’t get ahead. I have been running a nonprofit for years, and I’ve kept this bakery open out of sheer will and stubbornness. I am tired and out of ideas, so it is time for me to move on.

To our 2026 wedding clients, please don’t panic, I will be contacting each of you in the coming weeks. And I have a potential solution: Our head baker Rachel has always wanted to open her own business, and now she has the opportunity! Rachel has been baking all of your cakes and cupcakes for years, and she has my blessing to continue baking our recipes. Our managers and head decorator will be going with her. She only has 2 caveats on her new venture- it can’t be called “Classy Girl Cupcakes”, and it can’t be in our current space. Because I want it to be hers, and I don’t want anyone to think it’s mine. She deserves autonomy in fulfilling her own dreams, to start small and build it her way. Please support her once she opens🙏

Rachel is looking for commercial space to rent, preferably downtown Milwaukee, east side to Shorewood. She has a realtor helping her look, but if anyone knows of off market spaces, please DM us! Her goal is to open by spring so she can fulfill the wedding orders, though of course those clients have the option to cancel if they prefer.

I am so grateful for all of your support over the years, and I hope you will stop in or place one last order in the next month. We would love to see you! And then your super easy New Year’s resolution can be “no cupcakes til Rachel opens her bakery”:)

Thank you from the bottom of my heart,
Erica Elia

✨💚Have a Wicked birthday! 🩷🫧
11/20/2025

✨💚Have a Wicked birthday! 🩷🫧

Stop in and try our Tiramisu Jumbo cupcake filled with a coffee mousse. Limited quantity available, so hurry in! ☕️🤎
11/19/2025

Stop in and try our Tiramisu Jumbo cupcake filled with a coffee mousse.
Limited quantity available, so hurry in!
☕️🤎

A cake for all the K-Pop Demon Hunters’ fans! 💜✨🎤🎶
11/12/2025

A cake for all the K-Pop Demon Hunters’ fans! 💜✨🎤🎶

Happy Halloween from the Classy Girls! 🧡🖤🌭⚾️🐮🦋🐱🐒
10/31/2025

Happy Halloween from the Classy Girls! 🧡🖤🌭⚾️🐮🦋🐱🐒

Have a killer birthday! 👀🔪🩸
10/28/2025

Have a killer birthday! 👀🔪🩸

Stop in and try our Caramel Apple and Pumpkin Spice jumbo filled cupcakes. They’re the perfect fall treat! 🍁🍏🎃
10/15/2025

Stop in and try our Caramel Apple and Pumpkin Spice jumbo filled cupcakes. They’re the perfect fall treat! 🍁🍏🎃

10/03/2025

Happy Taylor Swift day to all those that celebrate! 😉🪩🧡✨

Address

825 N Jefferson Street
Milwaukee, WI
53202

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 6pm
Tuesday 8am - 6pm
Wednesday 8am - 6pm
Thursday 8am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 4pm

Telephone

+14142701877

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Classy Girl Rebaked posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category