Theresa's Delectables, "Home of Theresa's Homemade Cheeseballs"

Theresa's Delectables, "Home of Theresa's Homemade Cheeseballs" Theresa's Homemade Cheeseballs are sold in over 30 locations across Indiana. Theresa's Delectables Bakery-Cafe is home to Theresa's Homemade Cheeseballs and features many sweet treats, hot breakfast and lunch, and other pantry items.

We are known best for our Cheeseballs, which are all made from scratch by hand. Our choice of cheese combinations give our Cheeseballs the smooth texture that people have come to love. We have two flavors; pimento & onion and jalapeño, and now a dessert S'mores cheeseball that can only be found at our store in Milford. Our Cheeseballs are well known throughout the Midwest and some have even made t

We are known best for our Cheeseballs, which are all made from scratch by hand. Our choice of cheese combinations give our Cheeseballs the smooth texture that people have come to love. We have two flavors; pimento & onion and jalapeño, and now a dessert S'mores cheeseball that can only be found at our store in Milford. Our Cheeseballs are well known throughout the Midwest and some have even made t

Operating as usual

We still have a few bigger items left.  We close at 2pm today. Hope to see you soon.
05/01/2021

We still have a few bigger items left. We close at 2pm today. Hope to see you soon.

04/30/2021

Well today has finally come. We will be closing our doors for our business at 4:00pm for the final time. All our 1lb Cheeseballs are $1 off. Many other discounts. It has truly been a pleasure serving you all throughout the years. We wish this day hadn’t come, but we know it is the right time.

Now, for tomorrow. We are having a big “everything is for sale”. We will have a limited amount of blueberry and cake donuts, possibly some turnovers, and any Cheeseballs that are left. No other food items will be available. Stop in if you might be interested. Have a glorious day.

Theresa and I would like to thank all of you, including those who have bought our Cheeseballs at other locations, for helping us make our dream come true. We have met so many people who we consider our friends, who have made this day possible. Now we are ready for our next stage in our life together. Thanks again.

04/27/2021

We have only four days left until we are closed. All one pound Cheeseballs are still $1 off. Don’t wait until it is too late. We close at 4:00pm Friday.

On this coming Saturday we are having a big sale of everything. All our supplies, equipment, furniture, everything. We can’t take it on retirement with us. We still have a stainless steel stove, white refrigerator, stainless steel convection oven, and a tall size baking rack, and so much more. Our price is low. Make offer if you want. 8am to 2pm on Saturday. Must take with you then. We have a lot. Come on in.

04/23/2021

Only seven days left until we are closed for good. Our one pound Cheeseballs are $1.00 off through to our closing day.

Starting on Saturday, May 1st, our Cheeseballs will be available at Harvest Coffee on Main St. here in Milford.

Thank you Milford.

We have some appliances still for sale.  The white refrigerator is $200.  The stainless steel refrigerator is $325.  The...
04/22/2021

We have some appliances still for sale. The white refrigerator is $200. The stainless steel refrigerator is $325. The stainless steel stove is $350. The stainless steel convection oven is $300. You can pre-buy them if you want , but will be available for pickup on Saturday, May 1st. That is our big sale.

04/22/2021

Only eight days left until we close for good. Remember, one pound Cheeseballs are $1.00 off through our last day. Get some sweets while you are here.

04/21/2021

Starting today until April 30th, our one pound Cheeseballs are $1.00 off.

We will be closing our store for good at the end of the day on April 30th. We will be retiring. Everything will be for sale on Saturday, May 1st., from 8-2. Check our previous posts for where you will be able to purchase our Cheeseballs after we close. All locations except Rise’n Roll will continue to sell them. The Cheeseballs live on!!!

Thanks for all the fun we have had over the years.

04/15/2021

Just a reminder, we will be closed on Friday 4/16, Saturday 4/17, Monday 4/19, and Tuesday 4/20. We will reopen on Wednesday 4/21 at 7am. Thanks

04/12/2021

As most should know by now, we will be closing on April 30. We are retiring. We have two refrigerators, one electric stove, and one newer commercial convection oven for sale. We have a long list of many items that are for sale except nothing can be picked up until Saturday, May 1st. We will be having a big sale on that day from 8:00am to 2:00pm unless sold out sooner.

Everything from bookcases to paper products to pastry fillings to equipment. It all goes. If anything is left we will have a moving sale on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, May 3rd, 4th, and 5th at our residence from 9:00am to 4:00pm. Any questions please stop in the store. We will not give information out over the phone and any other media. Thanks.

04/12/2021

We are only open until 4:00pm today. This is our new daily closing time, along with Saturday at 1:00pm through the end of April. Remember, all one pound Cheeseballs will be $1 off starting Wednesday, April 21 through the end of April. Have an awesome day everyone.

04/02/2021

Earlier in the week we posted all of the locations that you can buy our famous Theresa’s Homemade Cheeseballs. Please take note of those locations since some of you may have purchased them at Rise’n Roll who no longer carries them. Now for the bigger news I mentioned was coming later this week.

Theresa and I, after much thought and discussion, and knowing the time is right for us and the Cheeseballs, have decided to retire. We have thoroughly enjoyed meeting so many new and old friends, and with out a doubt feel humbled how many people like the Cheeseballs and that has enabled us to work together these last seven years.
What many people don’t know is we met each other while working together over 38 years ago. It has been our pleasure to help serve you and make upwards of 400,000 Cheeseballs during these last seven years. We are so happy that Theresa’s Homemade Cheeseballs will continue on after we retire. I’ll give more details later. We have decided now is the perfect time to “ride off into the sunset’ , that is Florida sunsets. I want to thank Theresa for putting up with me when we were knee deep in our 75 to 90 hour work weeks every week these last seven years. We keep growing closer through all our hard work. It is by God’s strength and blessings that we have been able to do all we have done.

Friday, April 30th, we will close for the last time. Effective Monday, April 12, our hours will change for the first time to 7am to 4pm Monday through Friday, and the same 7am to 1pm on Saturday.

Please check out our page daily, especially from April 21 through April 30. We have decided to go out big, so there will be lots of specials during those days.

We will be closed temporarily from April 16 through April 20 to get ready for our move and life change, but also to get ready for our final 10 days open. That is it for now, but we will post more as time allows. Again, thank you so much. We are truly blessed.

03/29/2021

Good morning everyone. Just wanted to put out an updated list of everywhere you can buy our Cheeseballs. Below is every location:

Wakarusa, Martins Custom Butchery
Osceola, Crystal Springs Creamery
Galen, MI, Payne Heritage Country Store
Winona Lake, Port Winona
Rochester, Harvest Moon
Lapse, Mac’s Market
Bremen, Rentown
Middlebury, Das Essenhaus
Middlebury, Heritage Ridge Creamery
Shipshewana, Yoder’s Meat & Cheese
Shipshewana, E&S Sales
Millersburg, Double R Groceries
Syracuse, Bales Butcher Shop
North Webster, Ace Hardware
North Manchester, Manchester Market Place

Of course we have them here because, well, we make them here.

Rise’n Roll no longer sells our Cheeseballs. Any they have are what is left from our last delivery the first week of March. Going forward, if you see any there after April 12, they are not ours.

We will have another big announcement later this week. Also giving a heads up, our website will not be available after April 26, at least for the month of May.

Thanks, and have a great day.

We have a distinct color showing up already.  It is less than two weeks until St. Patrick’s Day.  This is what we really...
03/04/2021

We have a distinct color showing up already. It is less than two weeks until St. Patrick’s Day. This is what we really call “going green”.

We have a distinct color showing up already. It is less than two weeks until St. Patrick’s Day. This is what we really call “going green”.

All our decorating sugars and sprinkles are 70 cents off today through April 30th.  Normal price is $2.50.Also while you...
03/04/2021

All our decorating sugars and sprinkles are 70 cents off today through April 30th. Normal price is $2.50.

Also while you are here we have many supplies for your own baking needs. Pie pans, cake boxes, cake boards, various boxes for packaging your goodies, jumbo cupcake lines, jumbo cupcake containers (singles and fours), pastry fillings (numerous flavors), yeast, butter, cream cheese, pie fillings, and so much more. Don’t pay for the box store prices. We have ours or your sweet treats covered.

All our decorating sugars and sprinkles are 70 cents off today through April 30th. Normal price is $2.50.

Also while you are here we have many supplies for your own baking needs. Pie pans, cake boxes, cake boards, various boxes for packaging your goodies, jumbo cupcake lines, jumbo cupcake containers (singles and fours), pastry fillings (numerous flavors), yeast, butter, cream cheese, pie fillings, and so much more. Don’t pay for the box store prices. We have ours or your sweet treats covered.

03/04/2021

How about our lunch special today? All for $5.50 you get any Kolache, a bowl of soup( today the choice is chicken’n noodle or chili), any regular cookie (iced cookies would be 25 cents more), and any soft drink or bottle of water. Our lunch specials are good from 11am to 2pm. Hope to see you soon.

02/16/2021

We will be opening at 7:30 this morning. A little snow to slow to slow you down. See you later.

Valentines Day is in three days. Are you ready?  Candy bouquet vases. Iced sugar cookies. Cupcakes.  Going fast.  See yo...
02/11/2021

Valentines Day is in three days. Are you ready? Candy bouquet vases. Iced sugar cookies. Cupcakes. Going fast. See you soon!!

Valentines Day is in three days. Are you ready? Candy bouquet vases. Iced sugar cookies. Cupcakes. Going fast. See you soon!!

01/30/2021

Snow is a coming. Lots of it maybe, with a lot of drifting. Picture it being 3:00 Sunday afternoon and you run out of snacks, especially Theresa’s Homemade Cheeseballs. Better stop in today before we close at 1:00. We might have other goodies too.

01/27/2021

Hot chocolate. Hot latte. Hot cappuccino. Hot coffee. Bowl of hot soup. A south of the border kolache. See the connection? Hot!!! On a cold day we have you “covered”. See you real soon.

Are you ready for your big game? Football or basketball.  We’re ready.  Stop in today.
01/27/2021

Are you ready for your big game? Football or basketball. We’re ready. Stop in today.

Valentines Day is coming soon. Are you ready?  We have the treats.  Stop in or order yours today.
01/27/2021

Valentines Day is coming soon. Are you ready? We have the treats. Stop in or order yours today.

01/25/2021

Snow or ice storm coming!! Stock up now on our Cheeseballs.!! What storm? Who cares!

01/08/2021

Today and tomorrow, Saturday, you will want to stop in and get your “supplies “ for this coming week. This includes our Theresa’s Homemade Cheeseballs. We will be closed from January 10 through January 17 for our annual one week shutdown.

You can buy our Cheeseballs at over 30 other locations, but all our other goodies are only available in our store.

Thank you for this past year for helping us , and so many other mom and pop small businesses survive and thrive. We will get some much needed rest and see you all when we’re back, ready to go at it again.

Don’t forget we are still open today and Saturday.

12/29/2020

We still have our Pumpkin Bars until January 9th. After that we won’t make them again until September. Get them now. We will continue to make them until that time.

We normally stop making them by the end of December, but they are still very popular so we will make them until our annual shut down from January 10 thru January 16.

See you soon!!

Well we have two days until this unusual year is behind us. So we thought we would help make it better right up to the e...
12/29/2020

Well we have two days until this unusual year is behind us. So we thought we would help make it better right up to the end. On Wednesday and Thursday, we will be selling our one pound Cheeseballs at $1.00 off both days. Wow!! Just in time for your New Years Eve get together.

Thank you so much for helping us make it through the year. Hope to see soon.

Well we have two days until this unusual year is behind us. So we thought we would help make it better right up to the end. On Wednesday and Thursday, we will be selling our one pound Cheeseballs at $1.00 off both days. Wow!! Just in time for your New Years Eve get together.

Thank you so much for helping us make it through the year. Hope to see soon.

Need a last minute gift. We have gift boxes with variety of treats. Come in Wednesday or Thursday. Hope to see you soon.
12/22/2020

Need a last minute gift. We have gift boxes with variety of treats. Come in Wednesday or Thursday. Hope to see you soon.

We have your Christmas cookies waiting for you.  Call in your order today.  We have them in the cases, but they go fast,...
12/17/2020

We have your Christmas cookies waiting for you. Call in your order today. We have them in the cases, but they go fast, all day. Still time to order for Christmas Eve.

Our Cheeseballs make excellent gifts.  They say the way to a man’s heart is through his stomach. Well, we got you covere...
12/17/2020

Our Cheeseballs make excellent gifts. They say the way to a man’s heart is through his stomach. Well, we got you covered. No limits.

One week until Christmas.  We have gift boxes to help you with your last minute presents. Stop in today.
12/17/2020

One week until Christmas. We have gift boxes to help you with your last minute presents. Stop in today.

The cases are ready. Come and get it!!  The shelves are also full. We baked, or you can get your baking supplies here.  ...
12/05/2020

The cases are ready. Come and get it!! The shelves are also full. We baked, or you can get your baking supplies here. Breakfast, lunch, snack, or just because. Variety!! Pickles, donuts, Kolaches, noodles, sprinkles, crackers, jams or jellies, pie fillings, pastries, pumpkin bars, stroopwaffles, Naomi’s Candies, salsa, cinnamon rolls, and of course the star of the show, Theresa’s Homemade Cheeseballs. See you soon!!

12/05/2020

Well today is the day!! The last day of our Cheeseballs special. All one pounders are $5.75. That is 50 cents off. No limits. Call ahead for large orders. We close at 1:00 today. We have your favorite crackers too. Oh, and we have the sweets. See you soon.

12/04/2020

Today is the second day of three that our Cheeseballs are special priced. $5.75 for our one pound. That is 50 cents off. See you soon.

12/02/2020

Our second Cheeseballs Special is Thursday, Friday, and Saturday this week. Our one pound Cheeseballs are 50 cents off. No limit, but we do ask that for more than six please call and order them so we will be sure to have them for you, and those immediately after you.

We are doing this because we normally have our Wawasee Middle School craft show this weekend, that has been canceled.

Starts tomorrow, ends Saturday at 1:00.

See you soon.

11/28/2020

Hey everyone! Today is Small Business Saturday. Take time today to visit and help out the small businesses in your area. All the big box stores and online giants had their day, now it’s time for the backbone of America. They all need our help. We are the businesses that have suffered the most because of COVID-19.

Besides our own made from scratch products we also carry four small business’s products. Help them out today, and everyday. You’ll taste the difference. Below is who we carry and some of what they make.

Kuhn’s Kannery - pickles, salsa, beets, noodles, pie fillings, and Amish peanut butter.

Kuhn’s Orchard - jams, jellies

Naomi’s Candies - peanut butter cups, chocolate covered pretzels, milk chocolate turtles, raspberry balls, chocolate covered Oreos, Buckeyes, mint meltaways, and many more.

Dutch Waffle Company - stroopwafels

And of course who could forget our own Theresa’s Homemade Cheeseballs, and so much more.

Have a good daily visiting with your local small businesses. They are also your friends and neighbors.

Thank you!!

11/26/2020

For those that may not know, we will be closed on Friday also, as we always do. We would like to give thanks to all of you who have helped support us these past 9 months and beyond. It has been very trying, but we know the worst trials are yet to come.

Please keep us and all the small mom and pop businesses in mind when you are in need of something. We are still fully open when so many are closing their indoor seating. We have been and are continuing to be very aggressive in our COVID sanitation. We still sanitize all areas of our customer service area after each and every customer. This includes our entry door, front counter, Cheeseballs cooler, and any shelves, tables, and chairs that might have had contact with someone. This we have not changed since day one of COVID.

So again, thank you. We are so blessed to have so many awesome customers, friends.

Address

207 N Higbee St
Milford, IN
46542

General information

Theresa and Randy's mission is to treat you as family, as a best friend, and have you try the best Cheeseballs around! Our customers will be able to tell that we are one-of-a-kind. We take pride in caring about the products we serve and the people we serve them to. We carefully crafted our recipes to give each customer a taste of home. From our cookies to our biscuits and gravy to our cheeseballs; our goal is to have every bite as comforting as the last. That's why we go the extra mile -- to ensure we live up to the title of a made-from-scratch bakery. We strive to make our repeat customers will feel as welcome as family members, and our first-time customers leave feeling satisfied with the warm service and good food. And our final goal is to have everyone try a cheeseball. No one can eat it just once!

Opening Hours

Monday 07:00 - 18:00
Tuesday 07:00 - 18:00
Wednesday 07:00 - 18:00
Thursday 07:00 - 18:00
Friday 07:00 - 18:00
Saturday 07:00 - 13:00

Telephone

(574) 361-8058

Website

Products

Theresa's Homemade Cheeseball

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Theresa's Delectables, "Home of Theresa's Homemade Cheeseballs" posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Theresa's Delectables, "Home of Theresa's Homemade Cheeseballs":

Videos

Our Story

After selling at annual craft shows for over 15 years, it became apparent that our customers wanted our Cheeseballs year-round. So on July 5th, 2014, we opened up our little store-front bakery as a new home to make our Cheeseballs. We started with less than 300 sq ft., and after taking over the unit next-door, we realized we still needed room to grow. One block away and a few years later, the bakery/cafe has expanded and our Cheeseballs are still made by hand by us: Theresa and Randy.

We take pride in being a mom-and-pop made from humble beginnings. If it wasn't for our loyal customers loving our Cheeseballs so much, we wouldn't be here today. We thank our customers for helping our Cheeseballs take off and expand and for helping our bakery/cafe venture reach new heights.

Nearby restaurants


Other Milford restaurants

Show All

Comments

I am so sorry that I haven't kept up with your previous posts -- we've tried calling a couple of times and no answer. Now we know why. So sad! Where are we going to get your delicious cheeseballs???? But wishing you a very happy retirement.
Are your cheeseballs sold at Rise and Roll?
Traveling any distance is worth the time and effort to get their cheese balls. You will want to try both regular and jalapeno. But you need to buy two because the first one will disappear quickly. Plus freezing the second is always an option. These make wonderful gifts. No need to dust or display ... just consume and enjoy!
Cheese ball has made it to Dublin!! Yum!!!!!
Purchased some of your cheese spread today at Harvest Moon north of Rochester and loved it. I was unaware of your business, but will be sure to purchase more now.
The coconut cream and lemon meringue pies you made for me were fantastic! I look forward to ordering more from you in the future! Thank you.
We were getting our motor coach worked on at Newmar in Nappanee and one morning someone from Rentown brought some samples into the customer service lounge. One of the items was your pimento spread. All I can say is "WOW" and I'm not a big pimento fan. I think everyone there headed to Rentown to buy a carton of it! We live in East Tennessee and only come to Nappanee for repairs which are few and far between. Is your pimento spread available in any stores in the Knoxville TN area? I'm not ashamed to say I'm addicted to it!
Do you the nitrition label for Theresa's Homemade cheeseball. I'm on weight watchers...need to figure out points. Thank you
Bought Spicy Cheese Ball while in Shipshewana. Oh my, delicious does not describe. On my way towards home (Alabama) now. Wish I had bought them out! Oh for a recipe. Sigh.