Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats

Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats, 16300 Middle Road, Mattituck, NY.

Homemade with love • Sweets • Savories • Breads
Custom baking for special occasions
Pre-Orders for your convenience
[email protected] • Ph/Txt 631-255-1940

❤️ A Little Update from Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats! ❤️First and foremost, we hope everyone fared okay through the storm an...
09/28/2026

❤️ A Little Update from Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats! ❤️
First and foremost, we hope everyone fared okay through the storm and that you and your loved ones are safe. We know there’s plenty of cleanup happening, and we’re thinking of everyone as we all get back to normal.
We’ll be taking today to regroup and let everyone tackle the aftermath of the storm.
Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats will be back open on Friday! 🧁
Thank you for your understanding, your continued support, and for being such a wonderful part of our little bake stand family. We can’t wait to see you all again soon!
Stay safe, take care of one another, and we’ll see you Friday! ❤️
— Sassy Sue

🌧️ Weather Update from Sassy Sue’s! 🌧️Mother Nature has other plans for us today! Due to the nor’easter and the weather ...
09/26/2026

🌧️ Weather Update from Sassy Sue’s! 🌧️

Mother Nature has other plans for us today! Due to the nor’easter and the weather conditions, Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats will be closed today.

We’re sorry to miss you, but keeping everyone safe comes first! We’ll be back with plenty of sweet treats once the storm passes.

Stay safe, stay cozy, and we’ll see you soon! ❤️🍪

Two weddings. Two love stories. A whole LOT of sweets. 💍💒🍰✨This past weekend was a busy one for Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats...
09/23/2026

Two weddings. Two love stories. A whole LOT of sweets. 💍💒🍰✨
This past weekend was a busy one for Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats, and we loved every second of it! 🤍
From one beautiful celebration to the next, we got to create sweet treats for TWO amazing couples — and honestly, we can’t pick a favorite. 😍
Swipe through to see some of the magic from the weekend! ✨
Congrats to both of our newlyweds! 🥂🤍 We’re so happy Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats got to be a little part of your big days!

🍂 HAPPY SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 20TH! 🍂Don’t let the rain get you down! We have plenty of sweet treats fresh from the oven to ...
09/20/2026

🍂 HAPPY SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 20TH! 🍂
Don’t let the rain get you down! We have plenty of sweet treats fresh from the oven to brighten your day.
• Sprinkle Me Happy Cookies are on the stand!
• Pumpkin Spice Sourdough Donuts are here to get you into those cozy fall vibes!
• Don’t forget to grab a jar of our LIMITED-BATCH Strawberry Peach Jam!
This is the LAST of our local strawberries that we froze, so once this batch is gone, we’ll have to wait until next year for more strawberry based jams (and all the delicious treats we make with them.)
Grab a treat, grab a jar of jam, and settle in for your afternoon football games! 🏈🍂
📍 16300 Middle Road, Cutchogue, NY
(Across from Sannino Vineyards)
Come see us and make this rainy Sunday a little sweeter!

So, what do cucumbers and figs have to do with a bake stand? 😂We’ve had a few people wonder about this, so we thought we...
09/13/2026

So, what do cucumbers and figs have to do with a bake stand? 😂
We’ve had a few people wonder about this, so we thought we’d share the story behind it.
Many years ago, my father-in-law worked for John Tuthill on Elijah Lane, where there was a farm stand. Later, when the house was built where our stand is today, he planted a wonderful garden and filled it with all kinds of things he loved to grow. He would put his fresh produce out front at a little stand for people to enjoy.
Gardening was something he truly loved, and that little stand became part of the property and part of our family. ❤️
Sadly, he has since passed away, and we miss him dearly. 💕But we love that a little piece of what he created is still here. His son has continued the gardening tradition, although perhaps not quite on the same grand scale as his dad!
And the family tradition didn’t stop with the garden. My 89-year-old mother-in-law has been making baked goods and keeping them on the stand for years, along with homemade pickles and sweet potato pies. ❤️ She has definitely done her part to keep that little stand full of homemade goodness!
You may even see a comeback of some of those old favorites in the near future…
So, alongside our baked goods, you might find cucumbers, figs, and other garden treasures on the stand.
The next time you see cucumbers sitting next to the cookies, you’ll know there’s a little more to the story than you might think. It’s a story about family, gardening, baking, memories, and traditions that have been passed down through the years.
And as for what cucumbers and figs have to do with a bake stand?
Absolutely nothing… and yet, somehow, everything. ❤️
We’re just happy to keep a little bit of the tradition growing!

🌧️ Rain, rain, go away! We’d love to see you today! Happy Sunday, September 13! 🌸We’re opening at 1:30 this afternoon! S...
09/13/2026

🌧️ Rain, rain, go away! We’d love to see you today!
Happy Sunday, September 13! 🌸
We’re opening at 1:30 this afternoon! Stop by, grab some delicious treats, and get cozy while you enjoy your afternoon football games. 🏈
We’ll have fresh-baked cookies, sweet potato biscuits, fruit scones, carrot cake cupcakes, along with all our other goodies! 🧁🍪🥐
And we also have fresh figs from our own trees! Someday, I’ll tell you the story of why we have some produce on the stand.
📍 Find us at 16300 Middle Rd., Cutchogue, right across from Sannino Vineyards.
Let us help make this rainy Sunday a little sweeter! Come see us, stock up on goodies for game day, and cozy up with something delicious. 🏈✨
We’ll see you at 1:30! 💕

🌞 Happy Saturday, September 12! 🌞I hope everyone had a wonderful week! The stand is OPEN today, and we have some delicio...
09/12/2026

🌞 Happy Saturday, September 12! 🌞
I hope everyone had a wonderful week! The stand is OPEN today, and we have some delicious treats waiting for you! 🍪🍞💕.
🍓 Raspberry Swirl Cookie — available with or without pistachio nuts and white chocolate
🍥 Fresh Sourdough Cinnamon Buns — baked fresh and ready for you!
🍑🥒 Peach Zucchini Crumb Bread — this will be the LAST WEEK to get it! Don’t miss out before it’s gone for the season!
🍫And Sassy Sue’s favorite cookie the decadent brownie cookies! I’ve also been thinking about starting pre-orders for our sourdough bread. I’ve noticed that a lot of people aren’t getting it when they come to the stand, and I’d love to make sure everyone who wants a loaf has a chance to get one. 🥖
Let me know your thoughts on pre-orders! And which days would you like to be able to pick up your sourdough? I’d love to hear what works best for everyone!
Enjoy this beautiful day, and stop by to get yourself a little treat! 🌸🍪
Hope to see you at the stand!
📍 16300 Middle Rd, Cutchogue
(across from Sannino Vineyards)

🚨 LAST CALL, PEOPLE! 🚨The End of Summer Bash wraps up TODAY, which means this is your LAST CHANCE to get your Sassy fix ...
09/07/2026

🚨 LAST CALL, PEOPLE! 🚨
The End of Summer Bash wraps up TODAY, which means this is your LAST CHANCE to get your Sassy fix before I disappear into my kitchen and pretend I don’t know how to turn the oven on. 😂
Did you get all your favorites?
If not… WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR?!
The stand is stocked with fresh goodies today, including:
🍑 Fresh Peach Rhubarb Crisp
🍪 Grandma’s Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
🥜 Classic Peanut Butter Cookies
Once today is over, the stand will be CLOSED until FRIDAY, so you’ve got one last shot to grab your goodies before Sassy takes a few days off. 😴
So come on down, grab a treat (or three… I’m not judging 😏), and send summer off with something delicious!
TODAY ONLY, FRIENDS!
Because tomorrow, there will be no cookies… only regrets. 😂Come see us at 16300 Middle Rd Cutchogue (across from Sannino Vineyards)

Happy Sunday — September 6!The Bake Stand is OPEN, and we’ve got a delicious lineup of sweet and savory treats today!• R...
09/06/2026

Happy Sunday — September 6!

The Bake Stand is OPEN, and we’ve got a delicious lineup of sweet and savory treats today!
• Raspberry Chocolate Chip Cookies — soft, chewy cookies packed with sweet raspberry flavor and plenty of chocolate chips. A delicious combination of fruity and chocolatey in every bite.
• Peanut Butter S’mores Bars — rich and chewy peanut butter bars layered with gooey marshmallow and chocolate for the ultimate s’mores-inspired treat.
• Sun-Dried Tomato Pesto Focaccia — soft, fluffy homemade focaccia topped with flavorful sun-dried tomato pesto. Savory, herby, and perfect for snacking or serving alongside a meal.
Stop by and grab your favorites while supplies last!

Find us at 16300 Route 48, Cutchogue, NY
(across from Sannino Vineyards)

Happy Saturday — September 5!The Bake Stand is OPEN, and today’s lineup is full of sweet, homemade treats!• Carrot Cake ...
09/05/2026

Happy Saturday — September 5!
The Bake Stand is OPEN, and today’s lineup is full of sweet, homemade treats!
• Carrot Cake Cupcakes & Mini Carrot Cake Loaves — moist, warmly spiced carrot cake packed with classic homemade flavor, finished with rich and creamy cream cheese frosting.
• Raspberry Almond Bites — buttery, tender little treats with sweet-tart raspberry flavor and a delicious hint of almond. The perfect little bite when you’re craving something sweet!
• Key Lime Squares — bright, zesty, and refreshing, with a perfectly sweet and tangy key lime filling over a buttery crust. The perfect balance of sweet and citrusy.
Come treat yourself this Saturday! Everything is freshly baked and available while supplies last.

16300 Route 48, Cutchogue, NY
(across from Sannino Vineyards)

Address

16300 Middle Road
Mattituck, NY
11935

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 7pm
Sunday 10am - 7pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sassy Sue’s Tasty Treats posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share