Erica’s Baking Company

Website

Erica’s Baking Company Louis gooey butter center. My name is Erica Miller and I come from a family where food is the center of life. Food has always been there as a way of connecting.
(1)

First created in 2011, our gooey butter cupcakes and bites have a beautiful, caramelized, chewy and slightly crispy crust on the outside, while keeping the classic and soft St. From my dad’s short-lived bakery when I was a little kid, to my Nan’s kitchen in Michigan City. And now to my own home with my husband, Jason, and two teenagers, Aaron and Julia. Some of the best times I’ve spent in the kitchen have been with my grandmother, Nan. She knew everything there is to know about cooking, and she taught me for 42 years. Our last time cooking together was in 2019. We were on the phone and she told me she couldn’t find her chicken recipe. I asked if it was the one with chicken and Swiss cheese. She said yes. I had her over to my house that weekend and we cooked her famous recipe together, side by side. It was such a meaningful moment in my life to be able to connect with her in the kitchen one more time. The one way we differed is that I love to bake. I’ve had a small business for the past 10 years called The Chocolate Rooster. Up until the quarantine, I’ve only focused on baked goods. All the sudden I found myself with extra time and started making YouTube videos and sharing some of my favorite cooking and baking tips, which has resulted in finally writing down my recipes so I can share them with you.

I got my second cup of coffee in and I’m ready to head to the kitchen and prep for this Saturday at the Lake St Louis Fa...
10/07/2026

I got my second cup of coffee in and I’m ready to head to the kitchen and prep for this Saturday at the Lake St Louis Farmers Market!

On tap today:
• Caramel - I changed it up a bit so it’s a little bit thicker and my God, it’s DELICIOUS 🤤
• Apple pie spice
• Pumpkin pie spice
• Prep apples using my handy dandy Apple Peeler Corer Slicer from The Pampered Chef - circa early 2000s
• Prep all batter to bake tomorrow
• Make content

10/07/2026
10/05/2026

Introducing our NEW
✨Solo Gooey Butter Bite Flights ✨
These are great for girls nights, w**ery trips, or just hanging at your house with your dogs and cats and glass of w**e, or in my case, coffee.

Get your hands on some …
Saturday, 10/10 8-12
LSL Farmers & Artists Market at The Meadows

10/04/2026

I’m across the street from St Paul’s Lutheran Church until 5:30 today!

150 Hwy D New Melle

10/03/2026
We’ll be at Oktoberfest in New Melle tomorrow from 11:30-5:30 with our gooey butter bites and cupcakes and I would love ...
10/03/2026

We’ll be at Oktoberfest in New Melle tomorrow from 11:30-5:30 with our gooey butter bites and cupcakes and I would love to see you there!!

WHEN: Oct 4th 11:30-5:30

WHERE: St Paul Lutheran Church
150 Hwy D
New Melle 63365

GOOEY BUTTER FLAVORS:
Original
Candy Apple
Pumpkin
Turtle
Addicted to Love (chocolate gooey butter w caramel, ganache and sea salt)

I was baking and addicted to love came on and I was listening to the words and was like a yeah, that’s what I’m calling the chocolate caramel & sea salt gooey butter.

I won’t be at the Lake St Louis Farmers Market tomorrow because I’m spending the day with my daughter in the ER. She’s g...
10/02/2026

I won’t be at the Lake St Louis Farmers Market tomorrow because I’m spending the day with my daughter in the ER. She’s going to be okay, but we’ve been here since early am and I will not be able to get to the kitchen today to finish everything for tomorrow.

HOWEVER - I WILL be at Octoberfest in New Melle on Sunday from 11:30-5?? I need to confirm the details and will get them out to everyone when I get home.

Here’s a little pic from LA 😊 🌴 ☀️

09/30/2026

🍂 We’re breaking out the fall favors this week at the LSL Farmers & Artists Market !! You can find us this Saturday (10/3) from 8-12 in the roundabout next to the clocktower.

This weeks flavors:
🍎🍏 Candy Apple Gooey Butters
🎃 Pumpkin Spice Gooey Butters
🐢 Turtle Gooey Butters

We’ll also have the OGs gooey butters and a limited amount of the Hybrids and chocolate roosters.

Thank everyone that came out to the LSL Farmers & Artists Market yesterday! It was a bit of a slow start, but we ended u...
09/27/2026

Thank everyone that came out to the LSL Farmers & Artists Market yesterday! It was a bit of a slow start, but we ended up selling out! Thank you so much!!

Our chocolate w caramel and sea salt is always the favorite!! We’ll have them again next Saturday! I need a name for it. Any suggestions??

Address

PO Box 1152
Marthasville, MO
63357

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 8am - 12pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Erica’s Baking Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share