Restaurants in Fire Island, NY

Home
United States
Fire Island

Census-designated place in Suffolk County, New York

Explore cafés, street food, desserts and world cuisines in Fire Island.

Want your business to be the top-listed restaurant in Fire Island, NY?

Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

A

Fire Island

Fire Island 11770

Directions

The Fire Island Beach House

4.6 (433)

B

The Fire Island Beach House

25 Cayuga Walk, Fire Island 11770

Call Directions

C

Pines Pantry

57 Picketty Ruff Walk, Fire Island 11782

Directions

Cherry Grove Pizza

5.0 (1)

D

Cherry Grove Pizza

179 Ocean Walk, Fire Island 11782

Pizza Place

Call Directions

Pines Bistro Caterers

E

Pines Bistro Caterers

36 Fire Island Boulevard, Fire Island 1178

Caterer

Directions

F

Island Pantry

92 Bayview Avenue E, Fire Island 11730

Call Directions

Graze South Bay

G

Graze South Bay

23 E Lighthouse Walk, Bay Shore, Fire Isla

Food Stall

Directions

Seven Seas Summer Sharehouse

Seven Seas Summer Sharehouse

49 E Lighthouse Walk, Fire Island 11706

4.6 (880)

H

Schooner Inn

57 Baywalk Avenue, Fire Island 11770

Call Directions

Seashore Condo Hotel Fire Island

I

Seashore Condo Hotel Fire Island

78 Bayview Walk, Fire Island 11770

Call Directions

J

Floyd's

158 Bayview Walk, Fire Island 11782

American Restaurant

Directions

Flavors Ocean Bay Park

K

Flavors Ocean Bay Park

44 Bayview Walk, Fire Island 11770

Ice Cream Shop

Directions

Cafés, coffee and desserts

Ice Cream Parlors

Fast food and casual dining

American, Caribbean and Pacific cuisine

American restaurants

Show all categories

Areas in Fire Island

Nearby restaurants